Mid-Year Reckoning by Armond White for CityArts

2012’s best s-far and Sarris remembered

By Armond White
This year I want to do the Mid-Year Reckoning differently, as a tribute to film critic Andrew Sarris’ recent passing. It was Sarris, during my grad school years at Columbia, who wisely advised that the percentage of good movies has not changed from the old days. But now that the output is larger, the significance of sifting-out the trash is more important than ever. Sarris’ indispensable work The American Cinema first published in 1968 used the Nouvelle Vague’s notion of auteurism (cinema authorship) to categorize all Hollywood film history up to that point.

Sarris’ commentary on over 200 directors was an awesome feat, combining scholarship with sharp perception. His extraordinary assessments should still structure anyone’s thinking about movies–American or global. Because The American Cinema emerged from cinema’s first half-century, it also preserves aesthetics and values (pillars from Griffith to Sternberg) that have been lost in recent years of criticism’s decline in which media and box-office presence is given importance over the individual visions that Sarris knew was what made cinema an art form. He articulated that belief with idiosyncratic precision that to this day–when both Hollywood and the critical “community” have lost self-respect–is still awesome to read.

Each summer, my Mid-Year assessment has always been a way to keep track of the movie year’s deluge which, given the dozen or more films that open every week, is more than can be reviewed. So, perhaps, the reckoning might benefit this time from following Sarris’ model–as a reminder of the standards a film-lover has every right to uphold.

I take great exception to the TV pundit whose memorial to Sarris cited that he “loved movies.” Sarris’ work was greater than any fan boy obsession–everybody “loves” movies but Sarris turned his interest into teaching, study and personal expression, the things that make criticism value, an art in its own right.

With continued respect for Sarris, one of the two critics who professionally and personally have meant the most to me, I repeat The American Cinema’s first nine top-to-bottom categories, citing the work of individual directors. It could help to understand how 2012’s best films so far might ultimately rank in film history, or–as Sarris crucially demonstrated–in a personal pantheon rigorous enough to share with the world.

Pantheon Directors
Unforgivable (Andre Techine)–a tumultuous view of private lives as society and society as family.

The Deep Blue Sea (Terence Davies)–examines the linkage of desire and despair to find the value of personal resurrection.

The Far Side of Paradise
Damsels in Distress (Whit Stillman)–the rare campus comedy genre visits private worlds that reflect the eccentricities we recognize deep down.

Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson)–compares the innocence of youth and maturity.

Dark Horse (Todd Solondz)–tragedy found in the comedy of hopes squandered by misguided fashions.

The Skinny (Patrik-Ian Polk)–clarifies the blur of sex and friendship that gay-life faces straight-on.

A Thousand Words (Brian Robbins)–a Hollywood satire so casually profound it scared off the industry and its fans.

Expressive Esoterica
Americano (Mathieu Demy)–an Oedipal odyssey that finds culture heritage in family legacy.

Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance (Neveldine-Taylor)–addresses action movie tropes to satirize the deficiencies of contemporary genre excess.

The Lady (Luc Besson)–eloquently acted political bio-pic, refined non-comic book heroism.

The Flowers of War (Zhang Yimou)–common tragedy and possibility, rapturously envisioned.

Fringe Benefits
Detention (Joseph Kahn)–traces moral chaos throughout recent pop history.

Chronicle (Jonathan Trank)–youth’s visionary search for meaning.

Wanderlust (David Wain)–audacious mockery of Occupy sentimentality and its outdated hippie heritage.

That’s My Boy (Sean Anders)–empathy, heredity and its discontents.

Joyful Noise (Todd Graff)–the anodyne effects of music and the movie-musical.

Less Than Meets the Eye
Roadie (Michael Cuesta)–great performance by Ron Eldard.

The Kid with a Bike (Dardennes Brothers)-modern neuroses given fairytale attention.

Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter (Timur Bekmambetov)–trash made uncommonly spectacular.

Lightly Likable: Being Flynn, Darling Companion, Man on a Ledge, Where Do Go From Here?

Strained Seriousness: The Turin Horse, Safe, Neil Young Journeys, Magic Mike

Make Way for the Clowns: Ted, The Dictator, Casa de mi Padre

Oddities, One-Shots and Newcomers: Seeking a Friend for the End of the World, Beasts of the Southern Wild, Gerhard Richter Painting, Locked Out, John Carter

Back to Top