Membership
- Thelma Adams
- US Weekly
- John Anderson
- Newsday
- Melissa Anderson
- Time Out New York
- David Ansen
- Newsweek
- Dwight Brown
- NNPA & UPSCALE
- Richard Corliss
- Time
- Mike D'Angelo
- Esquire Magazine
- David Denby
- New Yorker
- David Edelstein
- New York Magazine
- David Fear
- Time Out New York
- Marshall Fine
- Star Magazine
- Owen Gleiberman
- Entertainment Weekly
- J. Hoberman
- Village Voice
- Stuart Klawans
- The Nation
- Nathan Lee
- The Village Voice
- Lou Lumenick
- New York Post
- Joe Morgenstern
- Wall Street Journal
- Peter Rainer
- Christian Science Monitor
- Rex Reed
- New York Observer
- Joshua Rothkopf
- Time Out New York
- Leah Rozen
- People Magazine
- Andrew Sarris
- New York Observer
- Richard Schickel
- Time
- Lisa Schwarzbaum
- Entertainment Weekly
- Gene Seymour
- Newsday
- Steve Snyder
- New York Sun
- Jan Stuart
- Newsday
- Peter Travers
- Rolling Stone
- Elizabeth Weitzman
- New York Daily News
- Armond White
- NY Press
- Stephen Whitty
- Newhouse Newspapers
